In its Q3 2026 market commentary, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices New England Properties reported a recent Westport sale: a home listed at $9 million sold for $7.5 million, right across the street from a $50 million listing. In Q3 2026, single-family homes in Saugatuck sold at an average of 113.3% of list price. Westport buyers are discounting in one part of town and outbidding each other in another.
Most buyers walk into a Westport winter expecting the season to hand them leverage. In 2026, a buyer's leverage has depended on how many new listings reached their neighborhood. In the parts of town where new listings almost stopped, buyers are paying well over asking. Where listings came back, prices have eased. One part of town, Greens Farms, has given buyers real room to negotiate. Which neighborhood you shop in decides more about your offer than the month you make it.
October's townwide numbers point two directions at once
The Westport single-family figures for October 2026 look soft on top. Sales fell to 18 from 30 in October 2025, and the median sale price dropped 11.7% to $2,527,500. Yet buyers that month paid an average of 103.3% of list price, up from 99.9% a year earlier. Median days on market fell from 49 to 27.
The homes that sold were cheaper to begin with. The median list price of the homes that sold in October was 17.05% lower than in October 2025. Those less expensive houses still sold for more than their sellers asked. Across January through October 2026, the townwide median rose 4.35% to $2.4 million. The year-to-date average sale-to-list ratio was 103.6%.
New listings fell faster than sales. Only 33 came to market in October 2026, down 26.67% from 45 a year earlier. Through October, the year-to-date count was 376, against 426 at the same point in 2025. The shortfall hit some parts of town much harder than others.
Saugatuck had one new listing all summer
In Q3 2026, Saugatuck had exactly one new single-family listing, down from 12 in Q3 2025. Six homes sold there that quarter. The median sale price was $2.25 million, up 23.63%, and the median home went under contract in 9 days. The average sale-to-list ratio was 113.3%, compared with 98.1% in the same quarter a year before.
Six sales is a small sample, but the pattern holds across the year. From January through September 2026, Saugatuck had 19 new listings, down from 34 over the same months of 2025. Its year-to-date sale-to-list ratio was 107.3%. For a buyer, that means a Saugatuck list price is closer to an opening bid than a ceiling.
More homes are planned near the train station, but they won't be for sale. Westport Journal reported that Spinnaker filed a site plan on October 19 for 142 rental apartments and 3,838 square feet of retail at 606 Riverside Avenue, on part of the former Hamlet site. The Board of Selectmen approved a sewer connection for the project 3-0 on November 11. The proposal still has to go through a public hearing and a Planning and Zoning vote, according to Westport Journal. Even if it is approved, rentals do nothing for the shortage of single-family houses for sale in Saugatuck this winter.
Coleytown got more choice, and prices came down
Coleytown went the other way. New single-family listings there rose to 15 in Q3 2026 from 6 a year earlier, a 150% increase. The median sale price fell 17.31% to $2.15 million. Buyers still paid over asking, at 104.5% of list for the quarter. More choice brought the price level down without ending the competition.
October showed what happens when Coleytown supply holds up. Nine homes sold that month, against 3 in October 2025, at a median of $3.0 million. The average sale-to-list ratio slipped to 100.6%, and median days on market rose to 85. When homes sit that long before selling, a buyer has time for inspections, comparisons and a second visit.
Long Lots sits in between. In Q3 2026 it had 12 new listings against 9 a year earlier. The median sale price fell 9.97% to $2.55 million, and homes sold at 102.7% of list. In October, its two sales closed at an average of 108% of list.
Greens Farms is where buyers found room
You would expect Greens Farms to be the tightest market in town. New listings there fell to 5 in Q3 2026 from 15 a year earlier, and the quarter's median sale price jumped 38% to $3,175,000. Then September 2026 came in very differently. Four homes sold that month at a median of $2,391,250, and they averaged 93.3% of list price. The average home took 70 days to sell.
The year-to-date figures back this up. Median days on market in Greens Farms from January through September 2026 was 51, compared with 20 over the same months of 2025. The year-to-date sale-to-list ratio was 100.4%, second lowest in town after Compo Beach. Price is the likely reason. At a median above $3 million, Greens Farms buyers are spending more and taking their time. The $9 million listing that sold for $7.5 million shows the same caution at the top of the market.
John Raus of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices described the market in an April interview with Moffly Media. He said: "The best homes still sold quickly, and everything else had to work a little harder." In Greens Farms this fall, a home that has to work harder is also a home a buyer can negotiate on.
Westport's neighborhoods side by side
The latest figures for each area appear below. The reporting periods differ, so each row shows its own. Most of these neighborhoods record only a handful of sales a month, so a single closing can move a figure a long way.
| Area | Period | Median sale price | Avg. sale-to-list |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saugatuck | Q3 2026 | $2,250,000 | 113.3% |
| Roseville/North Ave | Jan–Oct 2026 | $2,310,500 | 108.8% |
| Compo South | Jan–Sept 2026 | $1,857,000 | 108.5% |
| Hunt Club | Jan–Oct 2026 | $3,338,000 | 105.2% |
| In-Town | Jan–Oct 2026 | $2,650,000 | 104.9% |
| Coleytown | Q3 2026 | $2,150,000 | 104.5% |
| Long Lots | Q3 2026 | $2,550,000 | 102.7% |
| Old Hill | Jan–Sept 2026 | $2,149,560 | 101.9% |
| Greens Farms | Jan–Sept 2026 | $3,150,000 | 100.4% |
| Compo Beach | Jan–Sept 2026 | $4,400,000 | 99.3% |
The top of the table is mostly the Saugatuck, Compo South and Roseville/North Ave areas. In October 2026, the two Roseville/North Ave sales closed at a median of $2,875,000 and averaged 109% of list. Compo Beach, at the bottom of the table, has the highest median of any area. It sits in the same price tier as Greens Farms, where buyers have negotiated harder.
Writing an offer this winter, by neighborhood
In Saugatuck, Compo South and Roseville/North Ave, expect to compete. Few homes are coming to market, and this year's sales have closed at 108% of list or more. A buyer waiting for the holiday lull to soften prices there is waiting on something the 2026 numbers have not shown. Sellers in those areas have a small pool of competing listings. In that position, preparation and presentation decide how far past asking an offer goes.
In Coleytown and Long Lots, more listings have given buyers more to choose from. Prices there are lower than a year ago and still a little above asking. A home that has been on the market past the neighborhood's usual pace is the one to look at closely.
In Greens Farms and Compo Beach, the higher price tiers, offers below list are happening and long days on market are common. Pricing a home correctly from the start matters most here. The $9 million listing that closed at $7.5 million shows what happens when the first price is too high.
Quick answers
Is Westport cheaper in the winter? Not on the 2026 evidence. In October 2026, a month when many people expect the market to slow, Westport single-family homes still sold at an average of 103.3% of list. The bigger difference is between neighborhoods.
Why did Westport's median price drop in October if homes sold over asking? The homes that sold were less expensive to begin with. The median list price of October's sales was 17.05% lower than a year earlier, and those homes still averaged 103.3% of list.
Will the Riverside Avenue project add homes for sale in Saugatuck? Spinnaker's filing for 606 Riverside Avenue is for 142 rental apartments, and it had not reached a Planning and Zoning hearing as of mid-November.
If you're thinking of selling in Westport, it helps to know whether your neighborhood behaves more like Saugatuck or more like Greens Farms. That decides how to price your home, how to prepare it and when to list it. Lynne Murphy can compare your home with the latest sales in your part of Westport and show you how staging fits into your pricing plan. Let's connect. Request your free home valuation.